A Preventable Attack

Featured Cases

Hamilton Wingo

A prominent Dallas theater director was severely beaten and robbed outside the Cityplace Target. Hamilton Wingo attorneys sued Target Corporation, alleging that store security failed to protect him and even discouraged him from calling police.

“Do not let him call the police. Don’t call the police,” the lawsuit quotes the store’s head of security as telling employees. “We have a police officer here, and we will take care of it.”

But there was no security to be found in the parking lot as Derek Whitener left the store. And when he got to his car, he was attacked by the same masked men whose presence had worried him enough to alert employees on his way into the store on Haskell Avenue.

Attorneys Chris Hamilton and Paul Wingo were asked to help a theater director after he was attacked in the parking lot of a local Target, resulting in brain injuries.

Derek Whitener is the artistic and education director of The Firehouse Theater in Farmers Branch, Texas. On January 14, 2017, he was confronted by two masked men in the parking lot of a Target in Uptown Dallas after stopping to pick up some groceries.

Suit Blames Target for Cityplace Attack - Hamilton Wingo

[ARTICLE] Fox, Lauren, “Suit blames Target for Cityplace attack, says muggers vowed to teach theater director ‘what fear is’.” Dallas Morning News, 22, June 2017

CARELESSLY MISHANDLED

Inside the store, Derek told Target employees, including the head of security, what had happened. Despite the fact that he was clearly unnerved, the employees’ response to Derek was clear: Do not call the police. We’ll handle the situation ourselves.

The store’s head of security confronted the two men who had approached Derek and asked them to leave the premises. Derek was then told that it was safe to return to his car. As he walked through the parking lot, alone, the two men returned. Reports say that both were wearing gorilla masks. One of them said, “We hearD that you fear us. We’re going to teach you what fear is.” The two men beat Derek with the wooden rod. He suffered a fractured skull and a catastrophic brain injury that left him with permanent damage. He has difficulty speaking and is unable to perform high-level motor tasks.

RESOLUTION

Derek was represented by Chris Hamilton and Paul Wingo who filed suit against Target, as well as the location’s head of security and three other employees. Hamilton claimed that the store was negligent in failing to call police to deal with the situation, and then by allowing Derek to walk back to his car without an escort.

“A store has an obligation to be honest with the customer, to not interfere with the customer calling the police, and to provide basic protection,” Hamilton said. “Target is systematically using security personnel that are only focused and trained on asset protection, and they apparently don’t consider the customers to be an asset.”

$Beloved theater director is left with a fractured skull after two masked men beat him with a 3ft wooden rod in Target parking lot - but they stole nothing$

[ARTICLE] Konstantinides, Anneta, “Beloved theater director is left with a fractured skull after two masked men beat him with a 3ft wooden rod in Target parking lot – but they stole nothing.” Daily Mail, 17, Jan. 2017

Hamilton showed that Derek’s attack wasn’t an isolated case and that from 2014-2017, more than 200 crimes had been reported in the immediate area.

“Work in theater is Derek’s passion, and it is really what drives him in continuing to try to recover,” Hamilton said at a news conference in downtown Dallas. “He’s at a 10 or 20 percent of work capacity versus where he was before.”

Fortunately, Hamilton Wingo was able to successfully resolve the case with a favorable confidential settlement. While Derek may never be the same after this tragic attack, at least he has the lifelong financial security to make sure he can focus on making the best recovery possible.